US raises NATO membership in exchange for Donbas withdrawal for first time, Zelenskyy says
The United States has for the first time raised the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO in exchange for withdrawing its forces from the Donbas region, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy told journalists on November 13.
According to Interfax-Ukraine, Zelenskyy said Washington had posed the question during negotiations but had not made a concrete proposal.
"The Americans asked: 'What if Ukraine were in NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?' That was the first time," Zelenskyy said.
Donbas is an industrial region in eastern Ukraine comprising Donetsk and Luhansk oblasts. Russia occupies most of the region but continues to demand that Ukrainian troops withdraw from the remaining Ukrainian-controlled areas of Donetsk oblast as a condition for ending the war.
Zelenskyy says Ukrainians must have a say
Zelenskyy said he would be prepared to put such a proposal before the Ukrainian public if the United States and other NATO members agreed on specific terms and credible security guarantees.
"If there is such a proposal, I, as president, will enter into an open dialogue with society," he said, emphasizing that he could not make such a decision unilaterally.
He also stressed that Ukraine would not recognize Russian sovereignty over any occupied Ukrainian territory, regardless of the outcome of negotiations.
Kyiv is currently discussing a broader security package with its partners, including NATO and EU guarantees, a strong Ukrainian military backed by weapons and long-term financing, and a funded postwar reconstruction plan.
What would the security guarantees actually mean?
Zelenskyy said the United States was discussing guarantees resembling NATO's Articles 4 and 5, which concern consultations when a member's security is threatened and collective defense in the event of an attack.
However, he questioned how such guarantees would work without an American military presence in Ukraine.
"If you give us something 'similar' to NATO, will there be American soldiers on our soil?" Zelenskyy said he had asked U.S. officials.
Their answer, he said, was no.
According to Zelenskyy, Washington has described the proposed arrangements as bilateral guarantees comparable to security agreements with Israel and some Middle Eastern countries.
He noted that American military bases and air defense systems in those countries provide a practical form of protection, but said Ukraine still needs clarity on what its own guarantees would entail.
The discussion comes as Russia continues to demand Ukraine's withdrawal from the remaining Ukrainian-held parts of Donetsk oblast. Zelenskyy has previously warned that surrendering the fortified cities of Sloviansk and Kramatorsk would leave other parts of Ukraine more vulnerable to a Russian advance.
No agreement on NATO membership, territorial withdrawal or the proposed security guarantees has been announced.