Pentagon official leaves Ukraine defense meeting before Kyiv's briefing after criticizing deep strikes - Telegraph

Senior Pentagon official Elbridge Colby left a meeting of Ukraine's Western defense partners early after criticizing Kyiv's long-range strikes inside Russia, missing a classified briefing by Ukraine's defense minister on the military impact of those attacks, The Telegraph reported on November 18.
Colby, the US under secretary of defense for policy, made the remarks during a November 17 meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group, also known as the Ramstein format, at NATO headquarters in Brussels.
According to German officials who spoke to The Telegraph, Colby argued that Ukrainian deep strikes had not helped bring the war to an end or significantly slowed Russia's advance on the battlefield.
His assessment reportedly surprised German, British and other European participants, who regard attacks on Russian military and energy infrastructure as an important part of Ukraine's defense strategy.
A German source said Colby left before Ukrainian Defense Minister Yevhenii Khmara delivered a classified presentation outlining the effects of Ukraine's long-range operations.
"He left immediately after his statement, he did not even listen to [Ukrainian] defence minister [Yevhenii] Khmara's classified presentation," the source told The Telegraph.
A second source confirmed that Colby departed early. US Ambassador to NATO Matthew Whitaker represented Washington for the remainder of the meeting.
The Telegraph reported that Colby was said to have left to catch a flight. He held a press conference at NATO headquarters later that afternoon before departing for the airport.
European officials challenge US position
German sources expressed concern that Colby's remarks appeared to echo Russia's arguments against Ukrainian strikes on targets deep inside its territory.
"In that room, the US was the one nation that was siding with Russia's narrative rather than Ukraine and the rest of the coalition," one German source told The Telegraph.
German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius publicly dismissed Colby's criticism as "stupid."
British Defense Secretary Wes Streeting defended Ukraine's deep strikes, saying they had "helped to degrade Putin's war machine, buying time and saving lives."
One German source also questioned the consistency of Washington's position, pointing to the United States' own use of long-range strikes in its war against Iran.
Ukraine has intensified attacks on Russian oil facilities, weapons production sites and military infrastructure in recent weeks.
The disagreement comes as US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner prepare to join Ukrainian and European officials in Berlin on November 19 for talks on postwar security guarantees and the next steps in negotiations with Russia.
- Share:
